Blog Post

6 Most Popular Piping Stress Analysis Software Packages Used In The Industry

Introduction:

Piping stress analysis constitutes a major portion of engineering work in most of the industries e.g. Power, Oil and Gas, Petrochemicals, Refineries, pulp and paper, chemicals, and process industry. The current trend in the EPC and owner sector is integrated systems of management, design, manufacturing, and construction. There are various software for stress analysis, some of them developed and used by big corporations for their own use particularly in the Nuclear industry. In this article, we will cover the 6 most commonly used piping stress analysis software. 

Piping Stress Analysis Software Tools:

1.    CAESAR II, by Hexagon

2.    Autopipe, by Bentley

3.    CAEPIPE, by SST USA

4.    Rohr2, by Sigma, Germany

5.    PEPS, by DST Engineering

6.    PASS/STRAT-PROF

Now let’s take a brief look on all this software one by one,

1. CAESAR II, by Hexagon:


Typical Caesar II model

Caesar II by Hexagon (Previously Intergraph) is arguably the most popular 3D tool for piping stress analysis. It enjoys the largest market share as a pipe stress package. Caesar II works on beam element method. It is used in the piping industry to understand and evaluate working piping models. Caesar II works on a color-coded system in the output report, which helps to understand the areas of concern in the piping system. The software can be easily integrated with other Hexagon 3D model software. CII is user-friendly and has a large database consisting of over 35 international and local codes (such as ASME B31.3, B31.4, B31.1, B31.8, European codes, and many more) making it much easier for the user to analyze a piping model in question.


Benefits and features of Caesar II(source: Hexagon PPM site_Caesar II features PDF):


  • Time required for modeling gets reduced as the software has a large database of all types of standard models. Most of these works with a single click.
  • The graphics involved in the modeling is highly optimized which helps to keep bigger models also smooth. It has an advanced analysis and stress reporting system.
  • The use of recommended load cases option is very handy to import all the important cases in one click.
  • Caesar II gives the user access of 3rd party Finite element analysis tool for FEA related checks. Advanced analysis features such as the use of ASME B31J.
  • Interfacing with most of the CAD-based software is robust.

2. Autopipe, by Bentley

Typical Autopipe model )

AutoPIPE is one of the most popular piping stress package in the EPC industry. The software is developed by Bentley Systems, a US based organization. Autopipe's cost-effective solution to design any plant piping including nuclear units makes it highly efficient and popular. It increases productivity and improves quality with special piping stress features such as both static and dynamic analysis, wave loading, fluid transients available. The software can be easily integrated with all other Bentley and 3rd party applications such as Smart Plant, Aveva E3D, Autodesk Plant 3D, PDS, CAESAR II etc. (Source: Few of the points taken from Bentley.com_Autopipe section)


For Nuclear applications, the software has AutoPIPE Nuclear.


AutoPIPE Nuclear(Source:  Bentley.com_Autopipe section): The software allows to analyze critical nuclear systems adhering to ASME Class 1, 2, or 3 standards. It gives the productive graphical CAD interface as well as a graphical view of results.

AutoPIPE Nuclear conforms with ASME NQA-1, ISO 9001, CSA N286.7-99, ASME N45.2, and 10CFR50 standards backed by several independent audits by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) customers and the Nuclear Procurement Issues Committee (NUPIC). 


Benefits and features of Autopipe (Source: Points taken from Bentley.com_Autopipe feature section):


  • Unique graphical user interface.
  • All major international and local codes (total 25) are included in the stress package.
  • Quality assurance as per 10CFR Part 50 Appendix B, 10CFR Part 21, and ASME NQA-1.
  • Advanced analysis features including the latest ASME B31J requirements, Stress intensification factors, fluid transient analysis


3. CAEPIPE, by SST Systems:

Typical Caepipe model


Caepipe is developed by SST Systems USA. It performs both linear and non-linear, static and dynamic piping stress calculations. It is used in EPC and client-based industries for e.g., oil and gas, power, nuclear, fertilizers, petrochemicals etc.


Benefits and feature of Caepipe (Source: points taken from sstusa.com_caepipe section):


  • Multiple windows of the model can be opened for the visual and textual detailing of the system.
  • System updates in a single-window gets updated in all the windows giving a dynamic real-time effect.
  • Advanced analysis features including the latest ASME B31J requirements.
  • Advanced Microsoft windows installation for better operation.


Typical Rohr2 model

Rohr2 is a leading piping stress software mainly used in Europe. This package is developed by SIGMA Ingenieurgesellschaft mbH.

The main tasks of ROHR2 are component analysis, construction, and structural analysis of complex piping systems and associated steel structures. ROHR2win is the pre- and postprocessor of ROHR2. All inputs can be made using ROHR2win. A wide range of control functions enables the user to check the input data easily. The software can be integrated with 3rd party applications such as Smart Plant, Aveva PDMS/ E3D, CAESAR II, Caepipe etc.


Benefits and features of Rohr2 (Source: Points taken from rohr2.com basics and feature section):


  • ROHR2 includes optional modules as ROHR2fesu (used for detail FEA analysis of branch connections, Trunnions, Junction stress checks, etc.) and ROHR2flange (Used for flange check evaluation).
  • ROHR2 consists of a good database of all international and European codes and standards such as, ASME B31.1, B31.3, B31.4, B31.8, CODETI, EN codes etc.
  • It offers transfer data with all major CAD and CAE systems.
  • Both dynamic and static analysis can be performed in Rohr2.


5. PEPS, by DST Computers


PEPS is developed by DST engineering of Switzerland. The software package contains PIPESTRESS, the stress analysis package and Editpipe, it’s pre and post processor. The package is claimed being used by more than 400 engineering organizations used in 30 countries.

The PEPS program is used for stress analysis of piping systems falling under nuclear Class 1, 2 & 3 and non-nuclear codes. It is being used as the main piping analysis software for calculations in the new reactors: EPR, AP1000 and AC-1000. Many of the piping calculations for Westinghouse AP600 plant were performed using PIPESTRESS and these calculations were accepted by the US NRC when they issued a standard plant license for the AP600. (Source: Points taken from dst.ch_PEPS part)


Benefits and features of PEPS   (Source: Points taken from dst.ch_product features part):

  • Up to 500 load cases and combinations.
  • Fully featured dynamic analysis.
  • Integrated XML database for fittings, pipe cross-sections and materials.
  • Advanced text editor environment with full syntax coloring.
  • Instant visualization of the piping model defined in the input file, with input error detection.
  • Accepted in the Nuclear industry meeting the code requirements of ASME sec III. systems 


PASS piping model

PASS/STRAT-PROF is a comprehensive piping stress analysis software with related sizing calculation adhering to national and international codes and standards. PASS is an intelligent software, where the piping model can be completed just like a 3D model software and can run the analysis with help of a push button.

The software user manual is available in English, Chinese and Russian language, which is an additional feature compared to other software packages. The software is readily used in the power, process, oil and gas and chemical industries.

PASS/START-PROF can import piping models ready for analysis from CADWorx, SmartPlant 3D, AVEVA PDMS, AVEVA E3D, Bentley Autopipe, CAESAR II, Autoplant, Smart 3D, etc. (Source: Points taken from passuite.com_PASS part)


Benefits and features of PASS (Source: Points taken from passuite.com_PASS features part)


  • User friendly interface.
  • Piping segments can be used separately for modeling.
  • Flexibility check for Equipment nozzles is available.
  • Output results can be analyzed using 3D interactive behaviors.
  • Specific behavior of long radius pipe is considered in the analysis.

Conclusion:

Piping stress analysis is an inevitable part of an EPC design engineering team. In this article, we have covered a brief introduction to all the major piping stress analysis software's used in the industry. Author has personally used a very robust software called STANPIPES in Nuclear industry for almost 20 years, however, it is a proprietary software at Ontario Power Generation (OPG Nuclear) at Pickering, Darlington Nuclear Power Generating Stations. Also used at Bruce Power in Canada. If you use any other software at your organization, please share it with us in the comments below or via an email to info@mecsengineering.com.   


A thorough knowledge of pipe stress and the relevant packages is an asset for any piping engineering group.

At MECS Engineering, we take care every aspect of the project using the most sophisticated software to meet the project and Code requirements. When we assemble a team for a project, we do it strategically to optimize the resources.

 This also gives us the opportunity to save on engineering costs and improve on project schedule. For any assistance or further information please contact us

Steam Piping Design
By Arvinder Singh 15 Aug, 2023
Steam piping design is a paramount consideration for engineers and designers working in industries. In this comprehensive article, we will explore the key aspects of steam piping design, including code requirements.
22 Jul, 2023
Pressure vessels are critical components used in a variety of industries for preserving and transporting fluids or gases under extreme pressure. The design of pressure vessels is critical to ensuring structural integrity, operating safety, and long-term reliability. We will go into the major features of pressure vessel design in this thorough guide, including internationally recognized regulations and standards, choice of materials, design factors, and testing techniques. Following Codes and Standards in Pressure Vessel Design To hold and transfer fluids or gases under high pressure, pressure vessels are essential parts utilized across industries. For pressure vessel design to be safe, dependable, and compliant, adherence to internationally recognized rules and standards is essential. Let's explore the main features of these regulations and standards in greater detail: ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code (BPVC): The ASME BPVC , which is widely used both domestically and internationally, offers detailed instructions for the creation, inspection, & testing of pressure vessels. It remains current with the most recent developments. European Pressure Equipment Directive (PED): A variety of pressure vessels are covered by the European Pressure Equipment Directive, which establishes safety standards for pressure equipment on the EU market. The "CE" marking must be complied with by manufacturers. Pressure Equipment Directive (PED): PED 2014/68/EU has taken the place of the previous edition, PED 97/23/EC. Even though they are no longer relevant, making the distinction between the two is important for historical references. Engineers guarantee pressure vessels satisfy safety standards by complying with these norms and standards, which also encourage dependability and adherence to best practices. Pressure vessel design: Material Selection For pressure vessels to resist the high pressures, wide temperature ranges, and corrosive conditions that they may experience, the correct materials must be used. The choice is dependent on variables like pressure rating, temperature restrictions, fluid characteristics, corrosion resistance, and manufacturing needs. Commonly Employed Materials in Pressure Vessel Design: Carbon Steel: Since it is very inexpensive, has high weldability, and has strong characteristics, carbon steel is frequently employed in the building of pressure vessels. It can be used in a wide range of applications with moderate pressures & temperatures. Stainless Steel: Due to its excellent mechanical qualities and strong corrosion resistance, stainless steel is the material of choice for tasks involving corrosive environments or fluids. There are several stainless steel grades that each offer varying degrees of corrosion resistance and strength. Alloy Steels: To improve their mechanical characteristics and corrosion resistance, alloy steels may also contain other elements like chromium, molybdenum, or nickel. Pressure vessels that encounter extreme temperatures and pressures frequently employ alloy steels. Non-Ferrous Metals: Non-ferrous metals like titanium, copper, and aluminum are employed in particular pressure vessel applications because they have special qualities like low weight or excellent conductivity. Design Considerations: Crafting the Perfect Vessel A pressure vessel must be designed with extreme care to ensure structural integrity and top performance. To design a vessel that excels in both functionality and safety, engineers take into account many important criteria. Let's look at the main factors to take into account while designing the ideal pressure vessel: Dimensions, shape, and thickness: It is essential to determine the optimal pressure vessel's shape, thickness, and dimensions to satisfy particular application requirements and retain structural integrity while in use. Rewarding Techniques: The ability of the pressure vessel to endure internal and external forces is improved by using the proper reinforcing techniques, such as stiffeners, skirts, or rings, ensuring stability and longevity. Nozzles, Manways, Supports, and Access Points: The arrangement of nozzles, manways, supports, and access points is strategically planned to facilitate easy maintenance, inspection, and operation throughout the vessel's lifecycle. Vessel Orientation: It is important to evaluate the pressure vessel's orientation to maximize performance and ensure effective fluid flow while still meeting installation and space restrictions. Load distribution: To prevent stress concentrations and to ensure uniform pressure distribution for better safety and longevity, engineers carefully disperse loads across the pressure vessel. The upshot of these design considerations is a well-made pressure vessel that meets the demanding requirements of industrial processes while boasting structural integrity, safety, and effective functionality. Stress Analysis and Finite Element Analysis (FEA): The Path to Structural Integrity A pressure vessel's structural integrity must be guaranteed for it to operate safely and effectively. Engineers use thorough stress analysis to accomplish this with the use of cutting-edge computer technologies like Finite Element Analysis (FEA). Let's examine how FEA is essential to improving the design and functionality of pressure vessels: Finding High-Stress Concentration regions: FEA aids engineers in locating these regions inside the pressure vessel. Designers might concentrate on strengthening or optimizing such regions to reduce the likelihood of failures by locating these important points. Engineers can use FEA to forecast potential failure modes that pressure vessels can undergo under various operating circumstances. This insight enables preventative action to be performed to avoid disastrous results. Design Optimisation: Using FEA, engineers can fine-tune the pressure vessel's design for maximum effectiveness and safety by performing numerous simulations. Finding the best design to survive various stress conditions is made easier with the use of iterative analysis. Mitigating Stress-Related Problems: By providing engineers with insights into stress distribution patterns, FEA enables them to make design changes that reduce stress-related issues like fatigue or deformation. The FEA replicates a variety of working circumstances, such as external forces, temperature differences, and pressure variations. This accurate examination guarantees the pressure vessel's dependability in a variety of difficult settings. Pressure Vessel Design: Welding and Fabrication In the fabrication process for pressure vessel design, welding is a crucial step. To ensure that the pressure vessels have strong and dependable joints that can sustain the forces placed on the vessel during operation, proper welding techniques and processes are crucial. Let's examine this subject in more detail and include pertinent sub-points: 1. Welding Techniques in Pressure Vessel Fabrication: Submerged arc welding (SAW) is a common welding technique used in the construction of pressure vessels. It entails feeding a disposable electrode through a layer of flux granules. Flux protects the arc and the metal in the molten weld from air pollution. SAW is popular for having high deposition rates and great weld quality, which makes it appropriate for thick-pressure vessel sections. Stick welding is another name for shielded metal arc welding (SMAW), which use a consumable electrode that has been flux-coated. To form the weld, the welder manually strikes an arc and slides the electrode along the joint. SMAW is adaptable and frequently used for small-scale pressure vessel manufacturing or maintenance work. A non-consumable tungsten electrode is used in Gas Tungsten Arc Welding (GTAW), also known as TIG (Tungsten Inert Gas) welding, to create the weld. The area of the weld is protected from ambient contamination by an inert gas, usually argon. GTAW is preferred for critical applications and thin sections in pressure vessel fabrication due to its accuracy and capacity to generate high-quality welds. 2. Importance of Proper Welding Procedures: For consistent and dependable welds in pressure vessels, it's critical to adhere to approved welding processes. Based on the materials being joined, their thickness, and the particular welding process employed, qualified welding procedures are designed. Through a variety of tests, including macroscopic and microscopic exams, mechanical testing, and non-destructive testing (NDT), welding techniques are examined and qualified. 3. Quality Control Measures in Welding: NDT techniques are essential for checking the quality of welds and the overall vessel construction without causing damage. Typical NDT methods include: Radiography: To find internal flaws or weld discontinuities, X-ray or gamma-ray imaging is performed. High-frequency sound waves are employed in ultrasonic testing (UT) to find defects or anomalies in the base materials and the weld. Dye Penetrant Inspection (DPI) involves applying a liquid dye penetrant to the weld's surface, removing the excess dye after a certain amount of time, and then applying developer to reveal any surface-breaking flaws. Visual Inspection: Visual inspection is a simple but crucial stage in determining the quality of a weld. It entails looking for surface imperfections, fissures, or other obvious flaws in the welds. Welder Qualification: Welders who are involved in the fabrication of pressure vessels must pass a qualification test to make sure they have the knowledge and abilities necessary to carry out the appropriate welding activities. 4. Welding Quality and Certification: Welding quality assurance is crucial to ensure that the pressure vessel meets design and safety standards. Properly executed welding procedures and quality control measures contribute to the overall safety and reliability of the pressure vessel. Compliance with welding codes and standards, such as those specified by ASME and other regulatory bodies, is necessary for obtaining certifications and approvals for pressure vessel use. Quality Assurance & Testing of Pressure Vessel: To make sure that the pressure vessel complies with design and safety requirements, welding quality assurance is essential. The total safety and dependability of the pressure vessel are boosted by properly carried out welding operations and quality control measures. For pressure vessel certifications and approvals, compliance with welding rules and standards, such as those outlined by ASME and other regulatory bodies, is required. Also Read : Design Basis : Why is it so crucial to have a well-defined Design basis document for a successful Projec t. Maintenance and Inspection: Sustaining Safe Operation To monitor the state of pressure vessels and guarantee their continuing safe operation, routine maintenance, and inspection are essential. Visual inspection, ultrasonic testing, magnetic particle inspection, and thickness measurements are a few inspection procedures that can assist find possible problems like corrosion, erosion, or material degradation. For pressure vessel safety and effectiveness, routine maintenance and inspection are essential: Early Issue Discovery: Timely inspections stop minor flaws from developing into serious ones, preventing potentially disastrous failures. Optimized Performance: Regular maintenance increases the effectiveness of pressure vessels, resulting in more affordable and dependable operation. Visual inspection, ultrasonic testing, magnetic particle inspection, and thickness measurements are inspection techniques that aid in finding faults and monitoring structural integrity. Potential Problems Can Be Reduced: Inspection techniques make it possible to identify corrosion, erosion, or material degradation early on, allowing for quick remedial action or safety precautions. Proactive maintenance keeps the vessel's structural integrity and safe operation intact through routine cleaning, repair, and component replacement. Regulation Compliance: Adhering to safety standards and codes assures lawful operation, prevents fines, and keeps operations open. Record-keeping: Thorough documenting of inspection outcomes and maintenance tasks supports upcoming judgment calls and compliance monitoring. Conclusion: The Path to Design Excellence The complex and crucial process of designing pressure vessels necessitates careful consideration of codes, materials, design parameters, stress analysis, fabrication methods, testing, and maintenance. Engineers may guarantee the safety, dependability, and performance of pressure vessels by adhering to international regulations and standards, using cutting-edge design tools, performing exhaustive testing, and putting in place strong quality assurance methods. Continuous dedication to design quality paves the path for efficient and flawless operation across a variety of industrial processes. Visit our website to know more about our services
Design Basis - for a successful Project
By Arvinder S. Chhabra 11 Mar, 2021
This article shares the lessons learned on a recently finished project by "MECS Engineering" with the engineering community, especially young aspiring engineers.
Piping design software tools
04 Feb, 2021
Want to have a good idea of piping software? Check out our latest article on various 3d piping design software used in the EPC and Owner sector.
A typical piping stress model (Source: CAESAR II)
By Arvinder S. Chhabra, M.Eng.,P.Eng. 30 Jan, 2021
This article presents a brief of Piping stress analysis basics with code equations and objectives. Check out the article for more.
Share by: